Skip to main content

Comprehensive vs Collision Auto Insurance

InsuranceSide-by-side comparison

Compare comprehensive and collision auto insurance, what each covers and when you actually need both.

Comprehensive Coverage compared with Collision Coverage, feature by feature
FeatureComprehensive CoverageCollision Coverage
What It CoversTheft, weather, vandalism, animal collisionsCrashes with another vehicle or object
Required by Lender?Yes if financedYes if financed
Required by State?NoNo
DeductibleYou choose ($250–$1,500)You choose ($250–$1,500)
Average Annual Cost~$170/yr~$370/yr
Most Useful WhenVehicle parked outside, theft-prone areaNew / financed cars; high-traffic driving
Drop WhenPremium > 10% of vehicle valueSame, when vehicle is old

Overview

Collision covers damage from hitting another vehicle or object. Comprehensive covers damage from everything else, theft, hail, fire, falling trees, animals. Both are usually optional (not required by state law) but typically required by lenders if you have a car loan.

Choose Comprehensive Coverage when

Keep comprehensive if your car is parked outdoors, you live in a hail-prone area, or theft is a real risk in your neighborhood.

Choose Collision Coverage when

Keep collision while your vehicle is financed or has meaningful resale value; drop it when premium exceeds ~10% of the car's value.

Our verdict

Carry both while your car is financed (required) or worth a few thousand dollars. As your car ages, the cost of comprehensive + collision can exceed the value of the car, once you could replace the vehicle in cash, dropping these is reasonable. Liability insurance is the truly essential piece and shouldn't be dropped.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between Comprehensive Coverage and Collision Coverage?
Collision covers damage from hitting another vehicle or object. Comprehensive covers damage from everything else, theft, hail, fire, falling trees, animals. Both are usually optional (not required by state law) but typically required by lenders if you have a car loan.
When should I choose Comprehensive Coverage over Collision Coverage?
Keep comprehensive if your car is parked outdoors, you live in a hail-prone area, or theft is a real risk in your neighborhood.
When should I choose Collision Coverage over Comprehensive Coverage?
Keep collision while your vehicle is financed or has meaningful resale value; drop it when premium exceeds ~10% of the car's value.

By the numbers

What the data says

National figures from the sources shown, as of the period on each card. They are context, not a forecast or advice for your situation.

Not sure which is right for you?

Warren looks at your accounts, income and goals, then gives a recommendation built for your situation.